Andersonvilles of the North

The Myths and Realities of Northern Treatment of Civil War Confederate Prisoners

Nonfiction, History, Americas, United States, Civil War Period (1850-1877), 19th Century
Cover of the book Andersonvilles of the North by James M. Gillispie, University of North Texas Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: James M. Gillispie ISBN: 9781574413700
Publisher: University of North Texas Press Publication: October 15, 2008
Imprint: Language: English
Author: James M. Gillispie
ISBN: 9781574413700
Publisher: University of North Texas Press
Publication: October 15, 2008
Imprint:
Language: English
Soon after the close of military operations in the American Civil War, another war began over how it would be remembered by future generations. The prisoner-of-war issue has figured prominently in Northern and Southern writing about the conflict. Northerners used tales of Andersonville to demonize the Confederacy, while Southerners vilified Northern prison policies to show the depths to which Yankees had sunk to attain victory. Over the years the postwar Northern portrayal of Andersonville as fiendishly designed to kill prisoners in mass quantities has largely been dismissed. The Lost Cause characterization of Union prison policies as criminally negligent and inhumane, however, has shown remarkable durability. Northern officials have been portrayed as turning their military prisons into concentration camps where Southern prisoners were poorly fed, clothed, and sheltered, resulting in inexcusably high numbers of deaths. Andersonvilles of the North, by James M. Gillispie, represents the first broad study to argue that the image of Union prison officials as negligent and cruel to Confederate prisoners is severely flawed. This study is not an attempt to whitewash Union prison policies or make light of Confederate prisoner mortality. But once the careful reader disregards unreliable postwar polemics, and focuses exclusively on the more reliable wartime records and documents from both Northern and Southern sources, then a much different, less negative, picture of Northern prison life emerges. While life in Northern prisons was difficult and potentially deadly, no evidence exists of a conspiracy to neglect or mistreat Southern captives. Confederate prisoners suffering and death were due to a number of factors, but it would seem that Yankee apathy and malice were rarely among them. In fact, likely the most significant single factor in Confederate (and all) prisoner mortality during the Civil War was the halting of the prisoner exchange cartel in the late spring of 1863. Though Northern officials have long been condemned for coldly calculating that doing so aided their war effort, the evidence convincingly suggests that the Souths staunch refusal to exchange black Union prisoners was actually the key sticking point in negotiations to resume exchanges from mid-1863 to 1865. Ultimately Gillispie concludes that Northern prisoner-of-war policies were far more humane and reasonable than generally depicted. His careful analysis will be welcomed by historians of the Civil War, the South, and of American history.
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Soon after the close of military operations in the American Civil War, another war began over how it would be remembered by future generations. The prisoner-of-war issue has figured prominently in Northern and Southern writing about the conflict. Northerners used tales of Andersonville to demonize the Confederacy, while Southerners vilified Northern prison policies to show the depths to which Yankees had sunk to attain victory. Over the years the postwar Northern portrayal of Andersonville as fiendishly designed to kill prisoners in mass quantities has largely been dismissed. The Lost Cause characterization of Union prison policies as criminally negligent and inhumane, however, has shown remarkable durability. Northern officials have been portrayed as turning their military prisons into concentration camps where Southern prisoners were poorly fed, clothed, and sheltered, resulting in inexcusably high numbers of deaths. Andersonvilles of the North, by James M. Gillispie, represents the first broad study to argue that the image of Union prison officials as negligent and cruel to Confederate prisoners is severely flawed. This study is not an attempt to whitewash Union prison policies or make light of Confederate prisoner mortality. But once the careful reader disregards unreliable postwar polemics, and focuses exclusively on the more reliable wartime records and documents from both Northern and Southern sources, then a much different, less negative, picture of Northern prison life emerges. While life in Northern prisons was difficult and potentially deadly, no evidence exists of a conspiracy to neglect or mistreat Southern captives. Confederate prisoners suffering and death were due to a number of factors, but it would seem that Yankee apathy and malice were rarely among them. In fact, likely the most significant single factor in Confederate (and all) prisoner mortality during the Civil War was the halting of the prisoner exchange cartel in the late spring of 1863. Though Northern officials have long been condemned for coldly calculating that doing so aided their war effort, the evidence convincingly suggests that the Souths staunch refusal to exchange black Union prisoners was actually the key sticking point in negotiations to resume exchanges from mid-1863 to 1865. Ultimately Gillispie concludes that Northern prisoner-of-war policies were far more humane and reasonable than generally depicted. His careful analysis will be welcomed by historians of the Civil War, the South, and of American history.

More books from University of North Texas Press

Cover of the book Ground Pounder: A Marine's Journey through South Vietnam, 1968-1969 by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book The Best American Newspaper Narratives, Volume 3 by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Minding the Store by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Whiskey River Ranger by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Savage Frontier Volume I 1835-1837: Rangers, Riflemen, and Indian Wars in Texas by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Confessions of a Horseshoer by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Rounded Up in Glory by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Out the Summerhill Road by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book The Sutton-Taylor Feud by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Pacific Blitzkrieg by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Changing the Tune by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Morning Comes to Elk Mountain by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book Accidental Activists by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book The San Saba Treasure by James M. Gillispie
Cover of the book He Rode with Butch and Sundance: The Story of Harvey "Kid Curry" Logan by James M. Gillispie
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy