Common Law Judging

Subjectivity, Impartiality, and the Making of Law

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, Government
Cover of the book Common Law Judging by Douglas E Edlin, University of Michigan Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Douglas E Edlin ISBN: 9780472122158
Publisher: University of Michigan Press Publication: August 3, 2016
Imprint: University of Michigan Press Language: English
Author: Douglas E Edlin
ISBN: 9780472122158
Publisher: University of Michigan Press
Publication: August 3, 2016
Imprint: University of Michigan Press
Language: English

Are judges supposed to be objective? Citizens, scholars, and legal professionals commonly assume that subjectivity and objectivity are opposites, with the corollary that subjectivity is a vice and objectivity is a virtue. These assumptions underlie passionate debates over adherence to original intent and judicial activism.

In Common Law Judging, Douglas Edlin challenges these widely held assumptions by reorienting the entire discussion. Rather than analyze judging in terms of objectivity and truth, he argues that we should instead approach the role of a judge’s individual perspective in terms of intersubjectivity and validity. Drawing upon Kantian aesthetic theory as well as case law, legal theory, and constitutional theory, Edlin develops a new conceptual framework for the respective roles of the individual judge and of the judiciary as an institution, as well as the relationship between them, as integral parts of the broader legal and political community. Specifically, Edlin situates a judge’s subjective responses within a form of legal reasoning and reflective judgment that must be communicated to different audiences.

Edlin concludes that the individual values and perspectives of judges are indispensable both to their judgments in specific cases and to the independence of the courts. According to the common law tradition, judicial subjectivity is a virtue, not a vice.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Are judges supposed to be objective? Citizens, scholars, and legal professionals commonly assume that subjectivity and objectivity are opposites, with the corollary that subjectivity is a vice and objectivity is a virtue. These assumptions underlie passionate debates over adherence to original intent and judicial activism.

In Common Law Judging, Douglas Edlin challenges these widely held assumptions by reorienting the entire discussion. Rather than analyze judging in terms of objectivity and truth, he argues that we should instead approach the role of a judge’s individual perspective in terms of intersubjectivity and validity. Drawing upon Kantian aesthetic theory as well as case law, legal theory, and constitutional theory, Edlin develops a new conceptual framework for the respective roles of the individual judge and of the judiciary as an institution, as well as the relationship between them, as integral parts of the broader legal and political community. Specifically, Edlin situates a judge’s subjective responses within a form of legal reasoning and reflective judgment that must be communicated to different audiences.

Edlin concludes that the individual values and perspectives of judges are indispensable both to their judgments in specific cases and to the independence of the courts. According to the common law tradition, judicial subjectivity is a virtue, not a vice.

More books from University of Michigan Press

Cover of the book LGBT Youth in America's Schools by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Democratization by Institutions by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Building the Cold War Consensus by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Printing and Prophecy by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Digital Tools in Urban Schools by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Justice and Injustice in Law and Legal Theory by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Mex-Ciné by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book The War in Their Minds by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Grit, Noise, and Revolution by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book The Culture of the Body by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Millennial Reflections on International Studies by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Recording Village Life by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book The Jews of Georgian England, 1714-1830 by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book Research Guide to Japanese Film Studies by Douglas E Edlin
Cover of the book The Most Noble of People by Douglas E Edlin
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy