Comparing Westminster

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, International, Foreign Legal Systems, Politics, History & Theory
Cover of the book Comparing Westminster by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller, OUP Oxford
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller ISBN: 9780191609817
Publisher: OUP Oxford Publication: August 27, 2009
Imprint: OUP Oxford Language: English
Author: R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
ISBN: 9780191609817
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Publication: August 27, 2009
Imprint: OUP Oxford
Language: English

This book explores how the governmental elites in Australia, Britain, Canada, New Zealand, and South Africa understand their Westminster system. It examines in detail four interrelated features of Westminster systems. Firstly, the increasing centralisation in collective, responsible cabinet government. Second, the constitutional convention of ministerial and collective responsibility. Third, the role of a professional, non-partisan public service. And finally, parliament's relationship to the executive. The authors explain the changes that have occured in the Westminster model by analysing four traditions: royal prerogative, responsible government, constitutional bureaucracy, and representative government. They suggest that each tradition has a recurring dilemma, between centralisation and decentralisation, party government and ministerial responsibility, professionalisation and politicisation, and finally elitism and participation. They go on to argue that these dilemmas recur in four present-day debates: the growth of prime ministerial power, the decline in individual and collective ministerial accountability, politicisation of the public service, and executive dominance of the legislature. They conclude by identifying five meanings of - or narratives about - Westminster. Firstly, 'Westminster as heritage' - elite actors' shared governmental narrative understood as both precedents and nostalgia. Second, 'Westminster as political tool' - the expedient cloak worn by governments and politicians to defend themselves and criticise opponents. Third, 'Westminster as legitimising tradition' - providing legitimacy and a context for elite actions, serving as a point of reference to navigate this uncertain world. Fourth, 'Westminster as institutional category' - it remains a useful descriptor of a loose family of governments with shared origins and characteristics. Finally, 'Westminster as an effective political system' - it is a more effective and efficient political system than consensual parliamentary governments. Westminster is a flexible family of ideas that is useful for many purposes and survives, even thrives, because of its meaning in use to élite actors.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

This book explores how the governmental elites in Australia, Britain, Canada, New Zealand, and South Africa understand their Westminster system. It examines in detail four interrelated features of Westminster systems. Firstly, the increasing centralisation in collective, responsible cabinet government. Second, the constitutional convention of ministerial and collective responsibility. Third, the role of a professional, non-partisan public service. And finally, parliament's relationship to the executive. The authors explain the changes that have occured in the Westminster model by analysing four traditions: royal prerogative, responsible government, constitutional bureaucracy, and representative government. They suggest that each tradition has a recurring dilemma, between centralisation and decentralisation, party government and ministerial responsibility, professionalisation and politicisation, and finally elitism and participation. They go on to argue that these dilemmas recur in four present-day debates: the growth of prime ministerial power, the decline in individual and collective ministerial accountability, politicisation of the public service, and executive dominance of the legislature. They conclude by identifying five meanings of - or narratives about - Westminster. Firstly, 'Westminster as heritage' - elite actors' shared governmental narrative understood as both precedents and nostalgia. Second, 'Westminster as political tool' - the expedient cloak worn by governments and politicians to defend themselves and criticise opponents. Third, 'Westminster as legitimising tradition' - providing legitimacy and a context for elite actions, serving as a point of reference to navigate this uncertain world. Fourth, 'Westminster as institutional category' - it remains a useful descriptor of a loose family of governments with shared origins and characteristics. Finally, 'Westminster as an effective political system' - it is a more effective and efficient political system than consensual parliamentary governments. Westminster is a flexible family of ideas that is useful for many purposes and survives, even thrives, because of its meaning in use to élite actors.

More books from OUP Oxford

Cover of the book Journey to the Centre of the Earth by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book The Limits of the Market by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Ezra and the Second Wilderness by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Data Protection: A Practical Guide to UK and EU Law by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book The Road to Stockholm: Nobel Prizes, Science, and Scientists by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book The Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Pillars of Evolution by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Liberalism with Excellence by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Health Inequalities by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Blackstone's Emergency Planning, Crisis and Disaster Management by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Extraterritorial Application of Human Rights Treaties by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Tracing the Roles of Soft Law in Human Rights by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book The Royal Air Force by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book The Constitutional Structure of Proportionality by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
Cover of the book Mathematics Rebooted by R. A.W. Rhodes, John Wanna, Patrick Weller
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy