Discretionary Justice

Pardon and Parole in New York from the Revolution to the Depression

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Legal History, Criminal law
Cover of the book Discretionary Justice by Carolyn Strange, NYU Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Carolyn Strange ISBN: 9781479810901
Publisher: NYU Press Publication: December 20, 2016
Imprint: NYU Press Language: English
Author: Carolyn Strange
ISBN: 9781479810901
Publisher: NYU Press
Publication: December 20, 2016
Imprint: NYU Press
Language: English

The pardon is an act of mercy, tied to the divine right of kings. Why did New York retain this mode of discretionary justice after the Revolution? And how did governors’ use of this prerogative change with the advent of the penitentiary and the introduction of parole? This book answers these questions by mining previously unexplored evidence held in official pardon registers, clemency files, prisoner aid association reports and parole records.

This is the first book to analyze the histories of mercy and parole through the same lens, as related but distinct forms of discretionary decision-making. It draws on governors’ public papers and private correspondence to probe their approach to clemency, and it uses qualitative and quantitative methods to profile petitions for mercy, highlighting controversial cases that stirred public debate. Political pressure to render the use of discretion more certain and less personal grew stronger over the nineteenth century, peaking during constitutional conventionsand reaching its height in the Progressive Era. Yet, New York’s legislators left the power to pardon in the governor’s hands, where it remains today.

Unlike previous works that portray parole as the successor to the pardon, this book shows that reliance upon and faith in discretion has proven remarkably resilient, even in the state that led the world toward penal modernity.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

The pardon is an act of mercy, tied to the divine right of kings. Why did New York retain this mode of discretionary justice after the Revolution? And how did governors’ use of this prerogative change with the advent of the penitentiary and the introduction of parole? This book answers these questions by mining previously unexplored evidence held in official pardon registers, clemency files, prisoner aid association reports and parole records.

This is the first book to analyze the histories of mercy and parole through the same lens, as related but distinct forms of discretionary decision-making. It draws on governors’ public papers and private correspondence to probe their approach to clemency, and it uses qualitative and quantitative methods to profile petitions for mercy, highlighting controversial cases that stirred public debate. Political pressure to render the use of discretion more certain and less personal grew stronger over the nineteenth century, peaking during constitutional conventionsand reaching its height in the Progressive Era. Yet, New York’s legislators left the power to pardon in the governor’s hands, where it remains today.

Unlike previous works that portray parole as the successor to the pardon, this book shows that reliance upon and faith in discretion has proven remarkably resilient, even in the state that led the world toward penal modernity.

More books from NYU Press

Cover of the book The Material Gene by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Deeper Shades of Purple by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Authors of Their Lives by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book The Emergence of American Zionism by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Immigration and Crime by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Religion in the Kitchen by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Why Girls Fight by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book After the War on Crime by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Modernity's Ear by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Consorts of the Caliphs by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book The Next Generation by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Poverty and the Underclass by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Sex and Sexuality in Early America by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Disagreements of the Jurists by Carolyn Strange
Cover of the book Trial by Jury by Carolyn Strange
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy