Fallibilism: Evidence and Knowledge

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Epistemology
Cover of the book Fallibilism: Evidence and Knowledge by Jessica Brown, OUP Oxford
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Jessica Brown ISBN: 9780192521927
Publisher: OUP Oxford Publication: April 5, 2018
Imprint: OUP Oxford Language: English
Author: Jessica Brown
ISBN: 9780192521927
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Publication: April 5, 2018
Imprint: OUP Oxford
Language: English

What strength of evidence is required for knowledge? Ordinarily, we often claim to know something on the basis of evidence which doesn't guarantee its truth. For instance, one might claim to know that one sees a crow on the basis of visual experience even though having that experience does not guarantee that there is a crow (it might be a rook, or one might be dreaming). As a result, those wanting to avoid philosophical scepticism have standardly embraced "fallibilism": one can know a proposition on the basis of evidence that supports it even if the evidence doesn't guarantee its truth. Despite this, there's been a persistent temptation to endorse "infallibilism", according to which knowledge requires evidence that guarantees truth. For doesn't it sound contradictory to simultaneously claim to know and admit the possibility of error? Infallibilism is undergoing a contemporary renaissance. Furthermore, recent infallibilists make the surprising claim that they can avoid scepticism. Jessica Brown presents a fresh examination of the debate between these two positions. She argues that infallibilists can avoid scepticism only at the cost of problematic commitments concerning evidence and evidential support. Further, she argues that alleged objections to fallibilism are not compelling. She concludes that we should be fallibilists. In doing so, she discusses the nature of evidence, evidential support, justification, blamelessness, closure for knowledge, defeat, epistemic akrasia, practical reasoning, concessive knowledge attributions, and the threshold problem.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

What strength of evidence is required for knowledge? Ordinarily, we often claim to know something on the basis of evidence which doesn't guarantee its truth. For instance, one might claim to know that one sees a crow on the basis of visual experience even though having that experience does not guarantee that there is a crow (it might be a rook, or one might be dreaming). As a result, those wanting to avoid philosophical scepticism have standardly embraced "fallibilism": one can know a proposition on the basis of evidence that supports it even if the evidence doesn't guarantee its truth. Despite this, there's been a persistent temptation to endorse "infallibilism", according to which knowledge requires evidence that guarantees truth. For doesn't it sound contradictory to simultaneously claim to know and admit the possibility of error? Infallibilism is undergoing a contemporary renaissance. Furthermore, recent infallibilists make the surprising claim that they can avoid scepticism. Jessica Brown presents a fresh examination of the debate between these two positions. She argues that infallibilists can avoid scepticism only at the cost of problematic commitments concerning evidence and evidential support. Further, she argues that alleged objections to fallibilism are not compelling. She concludes that we should be fallibilists. In doing so, she discusses the nature of evidence, evidential support, justification, blamelessness, closure for knowledge, defeat, epistemic akrasia, practical reasoning, concessive knowledge attributions, and the threshold problem.

More books from OUP Oxford

Cover of the book Combinatorics: Ancient & Modern by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Practitioners' Guide to Human Rights Law in Armed Conflict by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Winston Churchill by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Algeria by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Comparative Reasoning in European Supreme Courts by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Sport: A Very Short Introduction by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Terrorism: A Very Short Introduction by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Hannibal's War by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Classical Literature: A Very Short Introduction by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Ark of Civilization by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book The China Choice by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book The Extended Phenotype by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book Absolutism in Renaissance Milan by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book A Dictionary of Biomedicine by Jessica Brown
Cover of the book The Oxford Handbook of Martin Luther's Theology by Jessica Brown
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy