In Defense of Moral Luck

Why Luck Often Affects Praiseworthiness and Blameworthiness

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Ethics & Moral Philosophy
Cover of the book In Defense of Moral Luck by Robert J. Hartman, Taylor and Francis
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Robert J. Hartman ISBN: 9781351866873
Publisher: Taylor and Francis Publication: March 27, 2017
Imprint: Routledge Language: English
Author: Robert J. Hartman
ISBN: 9781351866873
Publisher: Taylor and Francis
Publication: March 27, 2017
Imprint: Routledge
Language: English

The problem of moral luck is that there is a contradiction in our common sense ideas about moral responsibility. In one strand of our thinking, we believe that a person can become more blameworthy by luck. For example, two reckless drivers manage their vehicles in the same way, and one but not the other kills a pedestrian. We blame the killer driver more than the merely reckless driver, because we believe that the killer driver is more blameworthy. Nevertheless, this idea contradicts another feature of our thinking captured in this moral principle: A person’s blameworthiness cannot be affected by that which is not within her control. Thus, our ordinary thinking about moral responsibility implies that the drivers are and are not equally blameworthy.

In Defense of Moral Luck aims to make progress in resolving this contradiction. Hartman defends the claim that certain kinds of luck in results, circumstance, and character can partially determine the degree of a person’s blameworthiness. He also explains why there is a puzzle in our thinking about moral responsibility in the first place if luck often affects a person’s praiseworthiness and blameworthiness. Furthermore, the book’s methodology provides a unique way to advance the moral luck debate with arguments from diverse areas in philosophy that do not bottom out in standard pro-moral luck intuitions.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

The problem of moral luck is that there is a contradiction in our common sense ideas about moral responsibility. In one strand of our thinking, we believe that a person can become more blameworthy by luck. For example, two reckless drivers manage their vehicles in the same way, and one but not the other kills a pedestrian. We blame the killer driver more than the merely reckless driver, because we believe that the killer driver is more blameworthy. Nevertheless, this idea contradicts another feature of our thinking captured in this moral principle: A person’s blameworthiness cannot be affected by that which is not within her control. Thus, our ordinary thinking about moral responsibility implies that the drivers are and are not equally blameworthy.

In Defense of Moral Luck aims to make progress in resolving this contradiction. Hartman defends the claim that certain kinds of luck in results, circumstance, and character can partially determine the degree of a person’s blameworthiness. He also explains why there is a puzzle in our thinking about moral responsibility in the first place if luck often affects a person’s praiseworthiness and blameworthiness. Furthermore, the book’s methodology provides a unique way to advance the moral luck debate with arguments from diverse areas in philosophy that do not bottom out in standard pro-moral luck intuitions.

More books from Taylor and Francis

Cover of the book Foreign Direct Investment and the Regional Economy by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Motivating Ministers to Morality by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book The Origins of the French Revolutionary Wars by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Geographies of Modernism by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book The Idea of Home in Law by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Choice, Opportunity and Learning by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Facing the Nazi Past by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Manifestoes and Transformations in the Early Modernist City by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Caught in the Crossfire by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Personality Disorders and Eating Disorders: Exploring the Frontier by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Walls Have Feelings by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Public Relations and Individuality by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Language Processing in Bilinguals (RLE Linguistics C: Applied Linguistics) by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book Philanthropy and the Philanthropy Sector by Robert J. Hartman
Cover of the book The Politics of National Character by Robert J. Hartman
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy