Moral Responsibility and Desert of Praise and Blame

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Ethics & Moral Philosophy
Cover of the book Moral Responsibility and Desert of Praise and Blame by Audrey L. Anton, Lexington Books
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Audrey L. Anton ISBN: 9780739191767
Publisher: Lexington Books Publication: December 24, 2015
Imprint: Lexington Books Language: English
Author: Audrey L. Anton
ISBN: 9780739191767
Publisher: Lexington Books
Publication: December 24, 2015
Imprint: Lexington Books
Language: English

This book challenges a basic assumption held by many responsibility theorists: that agents must be morally responsible in the retrospective sense for anything in virtue of which they deserve praise or blame (the primacy assumption). Anton sets out to defeat this assumption by showing that accepting it as well as the much more intuitive causality assumption renders us incapable of making sense of cases whereby agents seem to deserve praise and blame. She argues that retrospective moral responsibility is a species of causal responsibility (the causality assumption). Then, she illustrates several examples in which agents are not causally responsible for any morally relevant consequences, but they seem to be deserving of praise or blame nonetheless. Anton concludes that such cases are counterexamples to the primacy assumption, and turns her attention towards discerning what grounds desert of praise and blame if not retrospective moral responsibility.
Anton advances the moral attitude account, whereby agents deserve praise and blame in virtue of moral attitudes they have in response to moral reasons. These moral attitudes must be sufficiently sincere, which means they reach a threshold that distinguishes such attitudes as eligible for praise and blame. Anton adds that whether one deserves praise or blame and to what degree is sensitive to the agent’s personal moral progress as well as the status quo of her society. This addition brings with it the welcome consequence that morality may be objective, but we are still justified in judging one another charitably based on personal and societal limitations.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

This book challenges a basic assumption held by many responsibility theorists: that agents must be morally responsible in the retrospective sense for anything in virtue of which they deserve praise or blame (the primacy assumption). Anton sets out to defeat this assumption by showing that accepting it as well as the much more intuitive causality assumption renders us incapable of making sense of cases whereby agents seem to deserve praise and blame. She argues that retrospective moral responsibility is a species of causal responsibility (the causality assumption). Then, she illustrates several examples in which agents are not causally responsible for any morally relevant consequences, but they seem to be deserving of praise or blame nonetheless. Anton concludes that such cases are counterexamples to the primacy assumption, and turns her attention towards discerning what grounds desert of praise and blame if not retrospective moral responsibility.
Anton advances the moral attitude account, whereby agents deserve praise and blame in virtue of moral attitudes they have in response to moral reasons. These moral attitudes must be sufficiently sincere, which means they reach a threshold that distinguishes such attitudes as eligible for praise and blame. Anton adds that whether one deserves praise or blame and to what degree is sensitive to the agent’s personal moral progress as well as the status quo of her society. This addition brings with it the welcome consequence that morality may be objective, but we are still justified in judging one another charitably based on personal and societal limitations.

More books from Lexington Books

Cover of the book Asian Tradition and Cosmopolitan Politics by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Modern Budget Forecasting in the American States by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Constructing the Stalinist Body by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Maine by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Studio-Based Approaches for Multimodal Projects by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book American Green by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book The Origins of Religious Violence by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Muslim Integration by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Communication, Digital Media, and Popular Culture in Korea by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Migrant Revolutions by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book New Dimensions of Chinese Foreign Policy by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Thomas Cromwell by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Alexander the Great and Hernán Cortés by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book Francis Bacon's New Atlantis in the Foundation of Modern Political Thought by Audrey L. Anton
Cover of the book The Trouble with Textbooks by Audrey L. Anton
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy