Opting for the Best

Oughts and Options

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Ethics & Moral Philosophy
Cover of the book Opting for the Best by Douglas W. Portmore, Oxford University Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Douglas W. Portmore ISBN: 9780190945374
Publisher: Oxford University Press Publication: June 11, 2019
Imprint: Oxford University Press Language: English
Author: Douglas W. Portmore
ISBN: 9780190945374
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Publication: June 11, 2019
Imprint: Oxford University Press
Language: English

We ought to opt for the best-that is, we ought to choose the option that is best in terms of whatever ultimately matters. So, if maximizing happiness is what ultimately matters, then we ought to perform the option that results in the most happiness. And if, instead, abiding by the Golden Rule is what ultimately matters, then we ought to perform the option that best abides by this rule. However, even if we know what ultimately matters, this is not always sufficient for determining which option we ought to perform. There are other questions that we need to consider as well. Which events are options for us? How do we rank our options-in terms of their own goodness or in terms of the goodness of the best options that entail them? How exactly does that which ultimately matters determine which options we ought to perform? In Opting for the Best, Douglas W. Portmore focuses on these three questions, which he argues can best be answered by putting aside any specific determination of what ultimately matters. He argues that tackling these three questions is crucial to solving many of the puzzles concerning what we ought to do, including those involving supererogation, indeterminate outcomes, overdetermined outcomes, predictable future misbehavior, and good acts that entail bad acts, among others. Engaging with arguments in areas as wide-ranging as action theory and deontic logic, the solutions that Portmore offers systematize our thinking about some of the most complex issues in practical philosophy.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

We ought to opt for the best-that is, we ought to choose the option that is best in terms of whatever ultimately matters. So, if maximizing happiness is what ultimately matters, then we ought to perform the option that results in the most happiness. And if, instead, abiding by the Golden Rule is what ultimately matters, then we ought to perform the option that best abides by this rule. However, even if we know what ultimately matters, this is not always sufficient for determining which option we ought to perform. There are other questions that we need to consider as well. Which events are options for us? How do we rank our options-in terms of their own goodness or in terms of the goodness of the best options that entail them? How exactly does that which ultimately matters determine which options we ought to perform? In Opting for the Best, Douglas W. Portmore focuses on these three questions, which he argues can best be answered by putting aside any specific determination of what ultimately matters. He argues that tackling these three questions is crucial to solving many of the puzzles concerning what we ought to do, including those involving supererogation, indeterminate outcomes, overdetermined outcomes, predictable future misbehavior, and good acts that entail bad acts, among others. Engaging with arguments in areas as wide-ranging as action theory and deontic logic, the solutions that Portmore offers systematize our thinking about some of the most complex issues in practical philosophy.

More books from Oxford University Press

Cover of the book The Great Conversation by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book When Information Came of Age by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book On Concepts, Modules, and Language by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Dive Deeper:Journeys with Moby-Dick by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Showdown in the Sonoran Desert by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book The Worlds of American Intellectual History by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Europe before Rome by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Americans and the California Dream, 1850-1915 by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book David, Saul, and God by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Wandering Poets and Other Essays on Late Greek Literature and Philosophy by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book North Korea by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Global Perspectives on Orchestras by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Nicolas Poussin by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book War Reparations and the UN Compensation Commission by Douglas W. Portmore
Cover of the book Surviving Triple-Negative Breast Cancer: Hope, Treatment, and Recovery by Douglas W. Portmore
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy