Personal Identity: Unity of Mind and Sameness Over Time

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy, Metaphysics
Cover of the book Personal Identity: Unity of Mind and Sameness Over Time by Michael Brulotte, Michael Brulotte
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Michael Brulotte ISBN: 9781301821808
Publisher: Michael Brulotte Publication: March 14, 2013
Imprint: Smashwords Edition Language: English
Author: Michael Brulotte
ISBN: 9781301821808
Publisher: Michael Brulotte
Publication: March 14, 2013
Imprint: Smashwords Edition
Language: English

Unlike many philosophical debates, the discussion about personal identity is not paralleled outside the domain of philosophy. In everyday life, there would be no disagreement about the sameness of identity over time. Children can understand that they were once babies, would-be criminals weigh the consequences of their actions, young adults put money away for retirement, and students pore over textbooks instead of going out to party. All of these typical behaviours and understandings take for granted a consistency of personal identity: the notion that each person will continue to be the same person over time. In metaphysics, however, such simplicity does not exist; concluding exactly what personal identity means and upon which criteria it is founded has given rise to substantial philosophical disagreement.

In this paper, I will investigate two problems that pertain to personal identity: first, I will discuss the unity of consciousness, which relates importantly to what consciousness most basically is, and second, I will discuss what accounts for the sameness of a particular personal identity over time. I believe these discussions represent the two most important pillars of personal identity for two reasons: first, because when we talk about any kind of identity, the fundamental, underlying assumptions are that it is singular (viz. that one person or one object cannot have multiple identities) and that it is temporal (viz. that it is meaningless to speak of identity that bears no relationship to time); second, because the implications of these pillars are the most grave and far-reaching—particularly vis-à-vis how we treat and punish other humans agents, for instance, in any criminal justice system.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Unlike many philosophical debates, the discussion about personal identity is not paralleled outside the domain of philosophy. In everyday life, there would be no disagreement about the sameness of identity over time. Children can understand that they were once babies, would-be criminals weigh the consequences of their actions, young adults put money away for retirement, and students pore over textbooks instead of going out to party. All of these typical behaviours and understandings take for granted a consistency of personal identity: the notion that each person will continue to be the same person over time. In metaphysics, however, such simplicity does not exist; concluding exactly what personal identity means and upon which criteria it is founded has given rise to substantial philosophical disagreement.

In this paper, I will investigate two problems that pertain to personal identity: first, I will discuss the unity of consciousness, which relates importantly to what consciousness most basically is, and second, I will discuss what accounts for the sameness of a particular personal identity over time. I believe these discussions represent the two most important pillars of personal identity for two reasons: first, because when we talk about any kind of identity, the fundamental, underlying assumptions are that it is singular (viz. that one person or one object cannot have multiple identities) and that it is temporal (viz. that it is meaningless to speak of identity that bears no relationship to time); second, because the implications of these pillars are the most grave and far-reaching—particularly vis-à-vis how we treat and punish other humans agents, for instance, in any criminal justice system.

More books from Metaphysics

Cover of the book Platonism, Naturalism, and Mathematical Knowledge by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book The Meaning of Aristotle’s ‘Ontology’ by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book The Genius Frequency by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Is the Apple Really Red? by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Gilles Deleuze, Postcolonial Theory, and the Philosophy of Limit by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Metaphysics by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Essays in the Metaphysics of Modality by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Kant y el problema de la metafísica by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book The Magic Language of the Fourth Way by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Krishnamurti by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Responsibility and Punishment by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Deep Awake by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Perceiving the World by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Parmenide contro Parmenide by Michael Brulotte
Cover of the book Isis Das göttliche weibliche Prinzip by Michael Brulotte
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy