Punishment and Desert

Nonfiction, Religion & Spirituality, Philosophy
Cover of the book Punishment and Desert by J. Kleinig, Springer Netherlands
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: J. Kleinig ISBN: 9789401020275
Publisher: Springer Netherlands Publication: December 6, 2012
Imprint: Springer Language: English
Author: J. Kleinig
ISBN: 9789401020275
Publisher: Springer Netherlands
Publication: December 6, 2012
Imprint: Springer
Language: English

Superficial acquaintance with the literature on punishment leaves a fairly definite impression. There are two approaches to punishment - retributive and utilitarian - and while some attempts may be made to reconcile them, it is the former rather than the latter which requires the reconciliation. Taken by itself the retributive approach is primitive and unenlightened, falling short of the rational civilized humanitarian values which we have now acquired. Certainly this is the dominant impression left by 'popular' discussions of the SUbject. And retributive vs. utilitarian seems to be the mould in which most philosophical dis­ cussions are cast. The issues are far more complex than this. Punishment may be con­ sidered in a great variety of contexts - legal, educational, parental, theological, informal, etc. - and in each of these contexts several im­ portant moral questions arise. Approaches which see only a simple choice between retributivism and utilitarianism tend to obscure this variety and plurality. But even more seriously, the distinction between retributivism and utilitarianism is far from clear. That it reflects the traditional distinction between deontological and teleological ap­ proaches to ethics serves to transfer rather than to resolve the un­ clarity. Usually it is said that retributive approaches seek to justify acts by reference to features which are intrinsic to them, whereas utilitarian approaches appeal to the consequences of such acts. This, however, makes assumptions about the individuation of acts which are difficult to justify.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Superficial acquaintance with the literature on punishment leaves a fairly definite impression. There are two approaches to punishment - retributive and utilitarian - and while some attempts may be made to reconcile them, it is the former rather than the latter which requires the reconciliation. Taken by itself the retributive approach is primitive and unenlightened, falling short of the rational civilized humanitarian values which we have now acquired. Certainly this is the dominant impression left by 'popular' discussions of the SUbject. And retributive vs. utilitarian seems to be the mould in which most philosophical dis­ cussions are cast. The issues are far more complex than this. Punishment may be con­ sidered in a great variety of contexts - legal, educational, parental, theological, informal, etc. - and in each of these contexts several im­ portant moral questions arise. Approaches which see only a simple choice between retributivism and utilitarianism tend to obscure this variety and plurality. But even more seriously, the distinction between retributivism and utilitarianism is far from clear. That it reflects the traditional distinction between deontological and teleological ap­ proaches to ethics serves to transfer rather than to resolve the un­ clarity. Usually it is said that retributive approaches seek to justify acts by reference to features which are intrinsic to them, whereas utilitarian approaches appeal to the consequences of such acts. This, however, makes assumptions about the individuation of acts which are difficult to justify.

More books from Springer Netherlands

Cover of the book Higher Education: Handbook of Theory and Research by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Glucagon in Gastroenterology by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Imagination and Critique by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Globalisation and National Identity in History Textbooks by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book MRI Atlas of Normal Anatomy by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Improving Quality Assurance in European Vocational Education and Training by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Das Zeitdenken bei Husserl, Heidegger und Ricoeur by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Probiotics 2 by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book The Rule of Law in Comparative Perspective by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book In vitro screening of plant resources for extra-nutritional attributes in ruminants: nuclear and related methodologies by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Etudes Penologiques Studies in Penology dedicated to the memory of Sir Lionel Fox, C.B., M.C. / Etudes Penologiques dédiées à la mémoire de Sir Lionel Fox, C.B., M.C. by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book The Legacy of John Austin's Jurisprudence by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Precedent in the United States Supreme Court by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book Lessons learned from Long-term Soil Fertility Management Experiments in Africa by J. Kleinig
Cover of the book What Counts in Teaching Mathematics by J. Kleinig
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy