The Dynamics of Judicial Independence

A Comparative Study of Courts in Malaysia and Pakistan

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Reference, International
Cover of the book The Dynamics of Judicial Independence by Lorne Neudorf, Springer International Publishing
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Lorne Neudorf ISBN: 9783319498843
Publisher: Springer International Publishing Publication: February 22, 2017
Imprint: Springer Language: English
Author: Lorne Neudorf
ISBN: 9783319498843
Publisher: Springer International Publishing
Publication: February 22, 2017
Imprint: Springer
Language: English

This book examines the legal principle of judicial independence in comparative perspective with the goal of advancing a better understanding of the idea of an independent judiciary more generally. From an initial survey of judicial systems in different countries, it is clear that the understanding and practice of judicial independence take a variety of forms. Scholarly literature likewise provides a range of views on what judicial independence means, with scholars often advocating a preferred conception of a model court for achieving ‘true judicial independence’ as part of a rule of law system. This book seeks to reorient the prevailing approach to the study of judicial independence by better understanding how judicial independence operates within domestic legal systems in its institutional and legal dimensions. It asks how and why different conceptualisations of judicial independence emerge over time by comparing detailed case studies of courts in two legally pluralistic states, which share inheritances of British rule and the common law. By tracing the development of judicial independence in the legal systems of Malaysia and Pakistan from the time of independence to the present, the book offers an insightful comparison of how judicial independence took shape and developed in these countries over time. From this comparison, it suggests a number of contextual factors that can be seen to play a role in the evolution of judicial independence. The study draws upon the significant divergence observed in the case studies to propose a refined understanding of the idea of an independent judiciary, termed the ‘pragmatic and context-sensitive theory’, which may be seen in contradistinction to a universal approach. While judicial independence responds to the core need of judges to be perceived as an impartial third party by constructing formal and informal constraints on the judge and relationships between judges and others, its meaning in a legal system is inevitably shaped by the judicial role along with other features at the domestic level. The book concludes that the adaptive and pragmatic qualities of judicial independence supply it with relevance and legitimacy within a domestic legal system.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

This book examines the legal principle of judicial independence in comparative perspective with the goal of advancing a better understanding of the idea of an independent judiciary more generally. From an initial survey of judicial systems in different countries, it is clear that the understanding and practice of judicial independence take a variety of forms. Scholarly literature likewise provides a range of views on what judicial independence means, with scholars often advocating a preferred conception of a model court for achieving ‘true judicial independence’ as part of a rule of law system. This book seeks to reorient the prevailing approach to the study of judicial independence by better understanding how judicial independence operates within domestic legal systems in its institutional and legal dimensions. It asks how and why different conceptualisations of judicial independence emerge over time by comparing detailed case studies of courts in two legally pluralistic states, which share inheritances of British rule and the common law. By tracing the development of judicial independence in the legal systems of Malaysia and Pakistan from the time of independence to the present, the book offers an insightful comparison of how judicial independence took shape and developed in these countries over time. From this comparison, it suggests a number of contextual factors that can be seen to play a role in the evolution of judicial independence. The study draws upon the significant divergence observed in the case studies to propose a refined understanding of the idea of an independent judiciary, termed the ‘pragmatic and context-sensitive theory’, which may be seen in contradistinction to a universal approach. While judicial independence responds to the core need of judges to be perceived as an impartial third party by constructing formal and informal constraints on the judge and relationships between judges and others, its meaning in a legal system is inevitably shaped by the judicial role along with other features at the domestic level. The book concludes that the adaptive and pragmatic qualities of judicial independence supply it with relevance and legitimacy within a domestic legal system.

More books from Springer International Publishing

Cover of the book Treatment of Pulmonary Hypertension by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Spin Physics in Semiconductors by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book School Turnaround Policies and Practices in the US by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Ductal Carcinoma in Situ of the Breast by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book The Brutalization of the World by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Elements of Cloud Storage Security by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Wireless Next Generation Networks by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book The Knowledge Growth Regime by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Quantum Systems under Gravitational Time Dilation by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Fraud Prevention in Online Digital Advertising by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Morphology of Electrochemically and Chemically Deposited Metals by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book In the Aftermath of Gezi by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Brand Fans by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book Piezo-Electric Electro-Acoustic Transducers by Lorne Neudorf
Cover of the book The Hyperuniverse Project and Maximality by Lorne Neudorf
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy