The Mediation Dilemma

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science, International, International Relations
Cover of the book The Mediation Dilemma by Kyle Beardsley, Cornell University Press
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Kyle Beardsley ISBN: 9780801462627
Publisher: Cornell University Press Publication: September 15, 2011
Imprint: Cornell University Press Language: English
Author: Kyle Beardsley
ISBN: 9780801462627
Publisher: Cornell University Press
Publication: September 15, 2011
Imprint: Cornell University Press
Language: English

Mediation has become a common technique for terminating violent conflicts both within and between states; while mediation has a strong record in reducing hostilities, it is not without its own problems. In The Mediation Dilemma, Kyle Beardsley highlights its long-term limitations. The result of this oft-superficial approach to peacemaking, immediate and reassuring as it may be, is often a fragile peace. With the intervention of a third-party mediator, warring parties may formally agree to concessions that are insupportable in the long term and soon enough find themselves at odds again.

Beardsley examines his argument empirically using two data sets and traces it through several historical cases: Henry Kissinger’s and Jimmy Carter’s initiatives in the Middle East, 1973–1979; Theodore Roosevelt’s 1905 mediation in the Russo-Japanese War; and Carter’s attempt to mediate in the 1994 North Korean nuclear crisis. He also draws upon the lessons of the 1993 Arusha Accords, the 1993 Oslo Accords, Haiti in 1994, the 2002 Ceasefire Agreement in Sri Lanka, and the 2005 Memorandum of Understanding in Aceh. Beardsley concludes that a reliance on mediation risks a greater chance of conflict relapse in the future, whereas the rejection of mediation risks ongoing bloodshed as war continues.

The trade-off between mediation’s short-term and long-term effects is stark when the third-party mediator adopts heavy-handed forms of leverage, and, Beardsley finds, multiple mediators and intergovernmental organizations also do relatively poorly in securing long-term peace. He finds that mediation has the greatest opportunity to foster both short-term and long-term peace when a single third party mediates among belligerents that can afford to wait for a self-enforcing arrangement to be reached.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Mediation has become a common technique for terminating violent conflicts both within and between states; while mediation has a strong record in reducing hostilities, it is not without its own problems. In The Mediation Dilemma, Kyle Beardsley highlights its long-term limitations. The result of this oft-superficial approach to peacemaking, immediate and reassuring as it may be, is often a fragile peace. With the intervention of a third-party mediator, warring parties may formally agree to concessions that are insupportable in the long term and soon enough find themselves at odds again.

Beardsley examines his argument empirically using two data sets and traces it through several historical cases: Henry Kissinger’s and Jimmy Carter’s initiatives in the Middle East, 1973–1979; Theodore Roosevelt’s 1905 mediation in the Russo-Japanese War; and Carter’s attempt to mediate in the 1994 North Korean nuclear crisis. He also draws upon the lessons of the 1993 Arusha Accords, the 1993 Oslo Accords, Haiti in 1994, the 2002 Ceasefire Agreement in Sri Lanka, and the 2005 Memorandum of Understanding in Aceh. Beardsley concludes that a reliance on mediation risks a greater chance of conflict relapse in the future, whereas the rejection of mediation risks ongoing bloodshed as war continues.

The trade-off between mediation’s short-term and long-term effects is stark when the third-party mediator adopts heavy-handed forms of leverage, and, Beardsley finds, multiple mediators and intergovernmental organizations also do relatively poorly in securing long-term peace. He finds that mediation has the greatest opportunity to foster both short-term and long-term peace when a single third party mediates among belligerents that can afford to wait for a self-enforcing arrangement to be reached.

More books from Cornell University Press

Cover of the book Rethinking the World by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Chinese Workers in Comparative Perspective by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Under the Strain of Color by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Radicals on the Road by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Going Native by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Sacrifice by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Labor Guide to Labor Law by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Workplace Flexibility by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book A Duterte Reader by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Ruffians, Yakuza, Nationalists by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Chaucer and the Poets by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book The Transmission of "Beowulf" by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book States and the Reemergence of Global Finance by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book The Sex of Class by Kyle Beardsley
Cover of the book Dangerous Familiars by Kyle Beardsley
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy