Where Our Protection Lies

Separation of Powers and Constitutional Review

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Civil Law, Social & Cultural Studies, Political Science
Cover of the book Where Our Protection Lies by Dimitrios Kyritsis, OUP Oxford
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Dimitrios Kyritsis ISBN: 9780191652431
Publisher: OUP Oxford Publication: August 4, 2017
Imprint: OUP Oxford Language: English
Author: Dimitrios Kyritsis
ISBN: 9780191652431
Publisher: OUP Oxford
Publication: August 4, 2017
Imprint: OUP Oxford
Language: English

In this book Dimitrios Kyritsis advances an original account of constitutional review of primary legislation for its compatibility with human rights. Key to it is the value of separation of powers. When the relationship between courts and the legislature realizes this value, it makes a stronger claim to moral legitimacy. Kyritsis steers a path between the two extremes of the sceptics and the enthusiasts. Against sceptics who claim that constitutional review is an affront to democracy he argues that it is a morally legitimate institutional option for democratic societies because it can provide an effective check on the legislature. Although the latter represents the people and should thus be given the initiative in designing government policy, it carries serious risks, which institutional design must seek to avert. Against enthusiasts he maintains that fundamental rights protection is not the exclusive province of courts but the responsibility of both the judiciary and the legislature. Although courts may sometimes be given the power to scrutinize legislation and even strike it down, if it violates human rights, they must also respect the legislature's important contribution to their joint project. Occasionally, they may even have a duty to defer to morally sub-optimal decisions, as far as rights protection is concerned. This is as it should be. Legitimacy demands less than the ideal. In turn, citizens ought to accept discounts on perfect justice for the sake of achieving a reasonably just and effective political order overall.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

In this book Dimitrios Kyritsis advances an original account of constitutional review of primary legislation for its compatibility with human rights. Key to it is the value of separation of powers. When the relationship between courts and the legislature realizes this value, it makes a stronger claim to moral legitimacy. Kyritsis steers a path between the two extremes of the sceptics and the enthusiasts. Against sceptics who claim that constitutional review is an affront to democracy he argues that it is a morally legitimate institutional option for democratic societies because it can provide an effective check on the legislature. Although the latter represents the people and should thus be given the initiative in designing government policy, it carries serious risks, which institutional design must seek to avert. Against enthusiasts he maintains that fundamental rights protection is not the exclusive province of courts but the responsibility of both the judiciary and the legislature. Although courts may sometimes be given the power to scrutinize legislation and even strike it down, if it violates human rights, they must also respect the legislature's important contribution to their joint project. Occasionally, they may even have a duty to defer to morally sub-optimal decisions, as far as rights protection is concerned. This is as it should be. Legitimacy demands less than the ideal. In turn, citizens ought to accept discounts on perfect justice for the sake of achieving a reasonably just and effective political order overall.

More books from OUP Oxford

Cover of the book Exile, Imprisonment, or Death by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book The Masnavi. Book Four by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book Impact of Addictive Substances and Behaviours on Individual and Societal Well-being by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book International Humanitarian Law and International Human Rights Law by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book Oxford Textbook of Medical Mycology by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book Concepts of Epidemiology by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book The Obligation to Extradite or Prosecute by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book New Frontiers in Mirror Neurons Research by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book The Royal Navy and the German Threat 1901-1914 by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book Sentientist Politics by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book National Identity in EU Law by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book Just So Stories for Little Children by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book The Karamazov Brothers by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book The Dharmasutras by Dimitrios Kyritsis
Cover of the book Constitutional Dialogue in Common Law Asia by Dimitrios Kyritsis
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy