Ambiguous Sacred: Between Religion and Spirituality

Published in Sociologia n. 2/2018 - Rivista quadrimestrale di Scienze Storiche e Sociali dell'Istituto Luigi Sturzo, diretta da Andrea Bixio

Nonfiction, Social & Cultural Studies, Social Science, Sociology
Cover of the book Ambiguous Sacred: Between Religion and Spirituality by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan, Gangemi Editore
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan ISBN: 9788849243703
Publisher: Gangemi Editore Publication: April 11, 2019
Imprint: Gangemi Editore Language: English
Author: Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
ISBN: 9788849243703
Publisher: Gangemi Editore
Publication: April 11, 2019
Imprint: Gangemi Editore
Language: English

The sociology of spirituality continues to highlight new socio-religious phenomena rooted in cultural revolutions in the modes of spiritual seeking (Wuthnow 1998), holistic milieux (Heelas and Woodhead 2005), and a ‘democratization of the sacred’ or restructuring of ways of legitimizing relating to the sacred (Giordan 2016). This ‘spiritual perspective’ brought new sociological insights into the analysis of the relationship with the sacred in two ways. First, it coupled the sacred to a subjective turn, locating the sacred in individual experiences in holistic milieux and radically proclaiming the sacralization of self-authority. Second, the theoretical focus on the spiritual turn and recent empirical studies on the religiosity/spirituality divide raised new questions for the sociological understanding of the sacred with elaborated theories of religious rituals, religious experience, or intrinsic religiosity (Durkheim 1960, Otto 1936, Simmel 1997), all needing inquiry into the sociological ambiguities of the sacred and the secular. The recent focus on the relationship between spirituality and the sacred (Heelas 2008, Voas and Bruce 2007, Versteeg 2007) evolved with the growing interest in the changing forms of religious life characterized by the global cultural trends of consumerism, pluralism, and individualism in the societies of modernity or postmodernity. New sociological arguments for the secularization thesis also drew attention. A recent plea appeared after the theoretical overview of empirical studies about spirituality, discerning theistic and holistic spiritualties with their different attitudes towards the sacred. Versteeg explains that theistic spirituality highlights an ‘external sacred’ for the individual, while the holistic type features a “connectedness to a sacred whole” (Versteeg 2007: 102). He notes that this distinction resembles the definitions of religion and spirituality introduced in the Kendall Project report by Heelas and Woodhead (2005). This allowed Voas and Bruce to defend the secularization thesis anew: if spirituality consists of “subjective-life forms of the sacred which emphasize inner sources of significance and authority and the cultivation of sacralization of unique subjective lives” (Voas and Bruce 2007: 44), it brings new “symptom of secularization, not a durable counterforce to it” (Voas and Bruce 2007: 43). The uncertainty of holistic spirituality practitioners in defining their experiences in terms of spirituality, and the distancing of holistic spirituality from theistic spirituality make it reasonable for sociologists to return to classical theories of the sacred that emphasized its ambiguous nature.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

The sociology of spirituality continues to highlight new socio-religious phenomena rooted in cultural revolutions in the modes of spiritual seeking (Wuthnow 1998), holistic milieux (Heelas and Woodhead 2005), and a ‘democratization of the sacred’ or restructuring of ways of legitimizing relating to the sacred (Giordan 2016). This ‘spiritual perspective’ brought new sociological insights into the analysis of the relationship with the sacred in two ways. First, it coupled the sacred to a subjective turn, locating the sacred in individual experiences in holistic milieux and radically proclaiming the sacralization of self-authority. Second, the theoretical focus on the spiritual turn and recent empirical studies on the religiosity/spirituality divide raised new questions for the sociological understanding of the sacred with elaborated theories of religious rituals, religious experience, or intrinsic religiosity (Durkheim 1960, Otto 1936, Simmel 1997), all needing inquiry into the sociological ambiguities of the sacred and the secular. The recent focus on the relationship between spirituality and the sacred (Heelas 2008, Voas and Bruce 2007, Versteeg 2007) evolved with the growing interest in the changing forms of religious life characterized by the global cultural trends of consumerism, pluralism, and individualism in the societies of modernity or postmodernity. New sociological arguments for the secularization thesis also drew attention. A recent plea appeared after the theoretical overview of empirical studies about spirituality, discerning theistic and holistic spiritualties with their different attitudes towards the sacred. Versteeg explains that theistic spirituality highlights an ‘external sacred’ for the individual, while the holistic type features a “connectedness to a sacred whole” (Versteeg 2007: 102). He notes that this distinction resembles the definitions of religion and spirituality introduced in the Kendall Project report by Heelas and Woodhead (2005). This allowed Voas and Bruce to defend the secularization thesis anew: if spirituality consists of “subjective-life forms of the sacred which emphasize inner sources of significance and authority and the cultivation of sacralization of unique subjective lives” (Voas and Bruce 2007: 44), it brings new “symptom of secularization, not a durable counterforce to it” (Voas and Bruce 2007: 43). The uncertainty of holistic spirituality practitioners in defining their experiences in terms of spirituality, and the distancing of holistic spirituality from theistic spirituality make it reasonable for sociologists to return to classical theories of the sacred that emphasized its ambiguous nature.

More books from Gangemi Editore

Cover of the book Nuove forme di politica, democrazia e partecipazione by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book «Restituiamo la Storia» - Atlante geostorico di Rodi by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Pescara senza rughe by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Tessere la speranza by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Il cinema incontra l’architettura: il ruolo dell’image-based practice nel dibattito | The cinema meets architecture: the role of image-based practice in the debate by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Geology and topography at Grotta delle Nottole by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Case Bastione: a prehistoric settlement in the Erei uplands (central Sicily) by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Le ville berlinesi di Hermann Muthesius by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Terremoto e architettura storica by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Roma il colore e la città by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Alfredo Lambertucci: disegnare per costruire by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book La rinascita dell’architettura Cham: un percorso di ricostruzione virtuale di architetture scomparse | The revival of Cham architecture: a path for the virtual reconstruction of lost architectures by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book 1° Rapporto sulla devianza minorile in Italia by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Castelli, Pievi, Abbazie by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
Cover of the book Chronology (and chronologies) of the Kura-Araxes culture in the Southern Caucasus: an integrative approach through Bayesian analysis by Anthony J. Blasi, Olga Breskaya, Giuseppe Giordan
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy