EC Competition Law - The Essential Facilities Doctrine

To what extent is the Essential Facilities Doctrine established in Community law and how has its application under Article 82 EC evolved over time?

Nonfiction, Reference & Language, Law, Business
Cover of the book EC Competition Law - The Essential Facilities Doctrine by Veronica Hagenfeldt, GRIN Verlag
View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart
Author: Veronica Hagenfeldt ISBN: 9783640880683
Publisher: GRIN Verlag Publication: March 30, 2011
Imprint: GRIN Verlag Language: English
Author: Veronica Hagenfeldt
ISBN: 9783640880683
Publisher: GRIN Verlag
Publication: March 30, 2011
Imprint: GRIN Verlag
Language: English

Scientific Essay from the year 2009 in the subject Law - Civil / Private / Trade / Anti Trust Law / Business Law, University of Edinburgh (School of Law), course: EC Competition Law, language: English, abstract: The first aim of this paper is to establish the Essential Facilities Doctrine's (EFD) undeniable existence in EC law and to determine how its application has evolved over time by analysing the relevant case law. By outlining the legal theory of the EFD, Part I shows that the Doctrine is a well-established competition law remedy within the refusal to supply framework of Article 82 EC. This paper argues that the EFD should be an exceptional measure, only applied after careful balancing of the dominant undertaking's freedom of contract and right to property against the potential benefits to consumer welfare. By investigating how the EFD has been applied practically in refusal to supply case law, the second half of Part I identifies the different criteria under which refusal to grant access to an essential facility was deemed to constitute an abuse, and concludes that the circumstances in which the EFD was initially applied were not consistent. It is submitted that it was not until the Bronner Judgment that the EU institutions began applying the EFD to refusal to supply cases within a coherent and sufficiently strict legal framework. Part II will deal with the second aim of this essay, namely to evaluate the legal evolution of the Doctrine's controversial application to Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs). Because compulsory licensing of IPRs can have grave negative repercussions on innovation and consumer welfare, this paper maintains that the EFD's application to IPRs should be exceptional and subject to the strictest of conditions. It accordingly supports the notion that IPRs require special deference in comparison to physical property rights, and notes that the EFD is applied to IPRs under stricter legal standards than when applied to other property rights. The second half of Part II investigates the Doctrine's application to refusal to licence cases. This paper identifies that there has recently been a significant and regrettable attenuation of the abovementioned stricter standards since the criteria of the exceptional circumstances test under which the EFD results in compulsory licensing have been indefensibly widened following the landmark Microsoft Judgment.

View on Amazon View on AbeBooks View on Kobo View on B.Depository View on eBay View on Walmart

Scientific Essay from the year 2009 in the subject Law - Civil / Private / Trade / Anti Trust Law / Business Law, University of Edinburgh (School of Law), course: EC Competition Law, language: English, abstract: The first aim of this paper is to establish the Essential Facilities Doctrine's (EFD) undeniable existence in EC law and to determine how its application has evolved over time by analysing the relevant case law. By outlining the legal theory of the EFD, Part I shows that the Doctrine is a well-established competition law remedy within the refusal to supply framework of Article 82 EC. This paper argues that the EFD should be an exceptional measure, only applied after careful balancing of the dominant undertaking's freedom of contract and right to property against the potential benefits to consumer welfare. By investigating how the EFD has been applied practically in refusal to supply case law, the second half of Part I identifies the different criteria under which refusal to grant access to an essential facility was deemed to constitute an abuse, and concludes that the circumstances in which the EFD was initially applied were not consistent. It is submitted that it was not until the Bronner Judgment that the EU institutions began applying the EFD to refusal to supply cases within a coherent and sufficiently strict legal framework. Part II will deal with the second aim of this essay, namely to evaluate the legal evolution of the Doctrine's controversial application to Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs). Because compulsory licensing of IPRs can have grave negative repercussions on innovation and consumer welfare, this paper maintains that the EFD's application to IPRs should be exceptional and subject to the strictest of conditions. It accordingly supports the notion that IPRs require special deference in comparison to physical property rights, and notes that the EFD is applied to IPRs under stricter legal standards than when applied to other property rights. The second half of Part II investigates the Doctrine's application to refusal to licence cases. This paper identifies that there has recently been a significant and regrettable attenuation of the abovementioned stricter standards since the criteria of the exceptional circumstances test under which the EFD results in compulsory licensing have been indefensibly widened following the landmark Microsoft Judgment.

More books from GRIN Verlag

Cover of the book Der Präfekt Pontius Pilatus und seine Rolle im Prozess gegen Jesus by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Die Schweigespirale - Eine Kritik anhand wahlpolitischer Aspekte by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Schulsozialarbeit. Die Kooperation von Jugendhilfe und Schule by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Krisenintervention durch den Berliner Krisendienst by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Eine Zusammenfassung der Inhalte des Films 'Das Tagebuch der Anne Frank' by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Brauchen Tageszeitungen Fachjournalisten? by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Biographieforschung und Geschichtswissenschaft by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Zwangsstörung - Begriffsklärung, Ursachen, Behandlungsmöglichkeiten by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Das Eisbergmodell. Ein Diskurs über ein ständig revitalisiertes Kommunikationsmodell by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Was ist mein Unternehmen wert? Unternehmensbewertungsverfahren by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Das frühmittelalterliche Dorf by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Möglichkeiten und Grenzen der Personalentwicklung by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Nation und Geschlecht auf symbolischer Ebene by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Eine kurze Werkanalyse von Immanuel Kants 'Zum ewigen Frieden' by Veronica Hagenfeldt
Cover of the book Die wirtschaftliche und soziale Krise im 7. Jahrhundert in Athen by Veronica Hagenfeldt
We use our own "cookies" and third party cookies to improve services and to see statistical information. By using this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy